Business News
The Dark Side of High-Volume Insurance Sales
Have we crossed the line?
Written by: Paul Bloodsworth
February 21, 2025
[5 minute read]
How We Got Here
The financial services industry relies on trust, but recent unethical practices have drawn the attention of regulators. In particular, the FCC has ramped up enforcement of TCPA regulations due to a surge in consumer complaints about unwanted solicitation calls. The question is: What triggered this crackdown?
We cover this in the video below:
The Dark Side of Insurance Sales: What Regulators Are Fighting
The Compliance Trap: How Unethical Sales Tactics Could Cost Millions
The Role of the Pandemic in Changing Sales Practices
Before COVID-19, insurance sales relied heavily on in-person meetings and wet signatures. However, the pandemic forced regulators to temporarily suspend these requirements, leading to an explosion in remote sales. This shift included:
- Increased Outbound Calls – With fewer restrictions, insurance agents significantly ramped up their call volume.
- Automated Sales Technology – Digital signature capabilities, AI-driven dialers, and automated messaging software enabled agents to reach exponentially more prospects in less time.
- High-Volume Lead Generation – Lead generators captured consumer data, often reselling it multiple times, resulting in a flood of unsolicited calls.
The Surge in Consumer Complaints
With agents making more calls than ever, consumer frustration skyrocketed. Complaints about excessive solicitation calls began pouring into the FCC, prompting regulators to take action. The key issues driving this response include:
- Unethical Lead Reselling – Consumers unknowingly consented to ongoing solicitation simply by filling out a single online form.
- Auto-Dialing Abuses – Some agents used AI-driven dialers to place hundreds of calls daily with minimal effort.
- TCPA Violations – Many companies ignored or misunderstood existing consent laws, leading to legal challenges and scrutiny from regulators.
Regulatory Action & Industry Impact
The FCC responded by enforcing TCPA laws more aggressively, attempting to rein in high-volume solicitation. Although recent court rulings have vacated the one-to-one consent rule, many expect further regulatory attempts in the future. Key takeaways include:
- Increased Compliance Oversight – Companies may face more scrutiny and potential legal consequences for unethical practices.
- Stronger Consumer Protection Rules – Future regulations could further restrict how consumer data is used and sold.
- Ethical Sales as a Competitive Advantage – Advisors who prioritize transparency and responsible outreach will differentiate themselves in the marketplace.
A Call for Ethical Practices
The insurance and financial industries provide essential services, but aggressive solicitation tactics have created widespread backlash.
While automation and AI tools are valuable, they must be used responsibly. Regulators are watching, and consumer frustration remains high.
A balanced approach—embracing efficiency while maintaining ethical standards—will ensure long-term success without the risk of crushing lawsuits.
As the saying goes: "Keep it between the ditches."
For a deeper dive, watch our full video where we break down these issues in detail.
Upcoming Podcast
Let's Get Clarity from a TCPA Attorney
We'll be announcing a date for an upcoming podcast with Eric Troutman. Eric and I recorded a podcast previously, but much has transpired in the interim. We'll be discussing these issues as they pertain specifically to the life insurance industry.
Share your thoughts in the comments section of the videos below!
Additional Resources:
📜 Read the official petition to the court from the IMC
🎧 Listen to our latest podcast
📩 Send us an email requesting to join our exclusive email list. (This is a small, private list. Include in your message which organization you represent.) Email to: marketing@go-excel.com